Peer Review Process

Procedures, stages, and principles of objective evaluation and peer review of manuscripts

Double-Blind Peer Review

All scientific articles submitted to the international scientific journal "SCIENCE AND INNOVATION" undergo a mandatory Double-Blind Peer Review process. In this system, both the authors and the reviewers remain entirely anonymous to each other. This policy guarantees maximum objectivity and eliminates any potential conflict of interest.

Workflow and Evaluation Stages

Stage 1

Initial Screening, Plagiarism & AI Check

The Managing Editor reviews the submitted manuscript for alignment with the journal's scope and technical formatting compliance. At this stage, the article passes through mandatory international academic quality filters:

• Plagiarism Control: Articles are screened using Turnitin and PlagiarismCheck systems. According to the journal requirements, the original text similarity score must be at least 80-85% original.

• Artificial Intelligence (AI) Check: Specialized international detectors are utilized to discover texts generated by ChatGPT, Claude, or other neural networks. Manuscripts fully written by AI are rejected immediately without being sent for peer review.

Plagiarism Check (>85% Original) AI Detector (Anti-ChatGPT)
1-3 days
Stage 2

Expert Analysis (Peer Reviewing)

Manuscripts that successfully pass the initial screening are assigned to at least two independent external experts (Ph.D. holders, Professors) with proven research tracks in the specific field. Reviewers critically evaluate the manuscript's relevance, methodology, and scientific novelty.

7-14 days
Stage 3

Editorial Decision

Based on the reviewers' formal reports, the Editorial Board makes one of three decisions: 1) Accept the manuscript without changes; 2) Return to the author for revision to address specific comments; 3) Reject due to low scientific quality or fundamental errors.

2-4 days
Stage 4

Publication & Indexing

The revised and fully accepted article is assigned a Digital Object Identifier (DOI), undergoes copyediting/typesetting, and is published in the upcoming issue under an Open Access license, followed by indexing in international databases.

Final Stage

Guidelines for Reviewers

Reviewers strictly adhere to the international regulations established by COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics) and ensure:

  • Absolute confidentiality regarding all details and content of the manuscript.
  • Purely objective, unbiased scientific evaluation, free from political, national, or personal prejudices.
  • Assisting the editorial board in identifying any suspected forms of plagiarism or academic misconduct.