This article examines and proposes a new approach to the
comprehensive assessment of the effectiveness of air traffic
management system modernization. The assessment is conducted in
three principal areas. The first area analyzes the reliability and fault
tolerance of radio navigation systems using Markov chains, the betafactor model for common-cause failures (CCFs), and Bayesian
statistical estimation methods. The second area examines the joint
application of inertial and satellite navigation systems and develops a
method for selecting the most appropriate configuration for aviation
facilities. The third area is devoted to the quantitative assessment of the
human-factor risk that has the greatest influence on accidents and
incidents within the air traffic management system.
By integrating these three areas into a single framework, a composite
modernization effectiveness index is proposed. The proposed method
was tested using data from the dual-channel VOR/DME radio
navigation system operated at Tashkent Airport. The difference
between the analytical calculations and the Monte Carlo simulation
results was only 2.3%, demonstrating the high accuracy of the model.
The results show that a 10% increase in the beta-factor coefficient for
common-cause failures raises the probability of hazardous misleading
navigation information by 34%. This reduces the compliance margin
relative to the safety requirements established for ICAO Category III
operations. The proposed composite index enables navigation service
organizations to compare modernization projects in terms of technical
reliability, human-factor effects, and economic efficiency, thereby
supporting the selection of the most appropriate decisions.
Kalit so'zlar
radio navigation systems; reliability; fault tolerance; Markov chains; common-cause failure (CCF); beta factor; Monte Carlo method; integrated inertial-satellite navigation system; human factor; air traffic management; modernization effectiveness; PBN/RNP
Foydalanilgan adabiyotlar
1. Garg, S., & Garg, S. Reliability analysis of communication systems using fault tree analysis.
International Journal of System Assurance Engineering and Management. 2020;11(2):321–334.
2. Dhillon, B. S. Engineering Systems Reliability, Safety, and Maintenance. Boca Raton: CRC Press;
2017.
INTERNATIONAL SCIENTIFIC JOURNAL SCIENCE AND INNOVATION
15 ISSN: 2181-3337 | SCIENTISTS.UZ
3. Rausand, M., & Bøhren, I. B. Risk Assessment: Theory, Methods, and Applications. 2nd ed. Hoboken:
Wiley; 2021.
4. EUROCONTROL. Safety Assessment Methodology—ESARR 6 Guidance Material. 2nd ed.
Brussels; 2018.
5. Meeker, W. Q., Escobar, L. A., & Pascual, F. G. Statistical Methods for Reliability Data. 2nd ed.
Hoboken: Wiley; 2022.
6. Ilcev, S. D. Global Aeronautical Communications, Navigation, and Surveillance. Vol. 1. Norwood:
Artech House; 2019.
7. An Application of a Modified Beta Factor Method for the Analysis of Software Common Cause
Failures. 2022. arXiv:2206.11321.
8. Kudratov, G., Eshmuradov, D., & Yadgarova, M. General issues of protection of backline computer
networks. Science and Innovation. 2022;1(8):684–688.
9. Jumamuratov, B. A., Eshmuradov, D. E., & Azizov, O. X. The future of aeronautical processing:
Opportunities and challenges of automation. Science and Innovation. 2023;2(4):231–236.
10. Jumamuratov, B. A., Eshmuradov, D. E., & Nabikhanova, A. D. Modern systems and tools for
monitoring the radio transparency of composite materials: Current status and development prospects.
In: Contemporary Problems and Development Prospects of Power Supply for Digital-Technology
Facilities. Special Issue 1. Tashkent; 2024. pp. 438–441.
11. Jumamuratov, B. A., Abdukayumov, A. A., & Eshmuradov, D. E. Metrological support for a device
used to monitor the radio transparency of composite materials. Milliy Standart [National Standard].
2024;(3):1–5.
12. Savin, D. I., & Korovin, A. V. Convergence of the secondary-processing algorithm in relative
navigation using multi-system global navigation satellite system user equipment. Teoriya i tekhnika
radiosvyazi [Theory and Technology of Radio Communication]. 2019;(1):49–54.
13. Attokurov, U., Omorova, S., & Eshmuradov, D. Analysis of the most hazardous interference affecting
the operation of a relay radio station. Science and Innovation. 2022;1(A6):484–488.
14. Kislukhin, G. A., Ryabov, D. A., & Burganskiy, A. I. Structure of a recurrent-neural-network system
for identifying strapdown inertial navigation system errors. In: XLV Academic Readings on
Cosmonautics: Abstracts. Moscow; 2021. pp. 529–530.
15. Zonov, N. I., & Moiseev, D. V. Assessment of satellite-navigation accuracy over a wide altitude range.
System Analysis, Control, and Navigation. 2018. pp. 132–133.
16. Novichkov, A. R., Egorushkin, A. Yu., & Fashchevskiy, N. N. Integration of a strapdown inertial
navigation system with a local positioning system based on ultra-wideband radio modules. In: XLIV
Academic Readings on Cosmonautics: Abstracts. Moscow; 2020. pp. 553–554.
17. Eshmuradov, D. E., Elmuradov, T. D., & Turaeva, N. M. Automation of aeronautical-information
processing based on multi-agent technologies. Scientific Bulletin of the Moscow State Technical
University of Civil Aviation. 2022;25(1):65–76.
18. Eshmuradov, D. E., et al. The need to use geographic information systems in air traffic control. Turkish
Journal of Computer and Mathematics Education (TURCOMAT). 2021;12(7):1972–1976.
19. Efficiency assessment in European air traffic management: A fundamental analysis of data, models,
and methods. Journal of Air Transport Management. 2024.
20. U.S. Government Accountability Office. Air Traffic Control Modernization: Program Management
Improvements Could Help FAA Address NextGen Delays and Challenges. GAO-24-105254.
Washington, DC; 2023.
21. U.S. Government Accountability Office. Air Traffic Control: Urgent FAA Actions Are Needed to
Modernize Aging Systems. GAO-25-107917. Washington, DC; 2024.
INTERNATIONAL SCIENTIFIC JOURNAL SCIENCE AND INNOVATION
16 ISSN: 2181-3337 | SCIENTISTS.UZ
22. Human factors analysis of air traffic safety based on the HFACS-BN model. Applied Sciences.
2019;9(23):5049.
23. Reva, O., Kamyshin, V., Borsuk, S., Shulgin, V., & Nevynitsyn, A. Qualitative indexes of air traffic
controllers’ attitudes toward mistake hazards. In: Proceedings of the International Conference on
Applied Human Factors and Ergonomics. Cham: Springer; 2021. pp. 618–624.
24. Zimmermann, N., & Mendonca, F. A. C. The impact of human factors and maintenance documentation
on aviation safety: An analysis of 15 years of accident data through the PEAR framework. The
Collegiate Aviation Review International. 2021.
25. Dill, E. T., Idris, H. R., et al. Required Navigation Performance (RNP) for precision approach and
landing with GNSS application. AIAA Aviation Forum. 2022. https://doi.org/10.2514/6.2022-3759.
26. Civil Aviation Safety Authority. Advisory Circular AC 91-05: Performance-Based Navigation.
Version 1.0; 2021
Maqolaga iqtibos keltirish andozasi
Eshmuradov D, Abdukayumov A, Saidova G, Elmuradov T (2026). METHODS FOR IMPROVING RADIO NAVIGATION
SYSTEM RELIABILITY IN THE COMPREHENSIVE
ASSESSMENT OF AIR TRAFFIC MANAGEMENT
SYSTEM MODERNIZATION EFFECTIVENESS. Science and Innovation, 5(7), 4-16. https://doi.org/10.67620/sai.57A0001